Afghan Star reflections

Afghan Star reflections

Pre-film thoughts: There was simply no way Afghanistan and Entertainment Stars would go well together because the culture so conservative and traditional!

Thoughts during the film: Either Setara or one of the crew members would be harassed or harmed as tension escalates and the “brazen” dance of Setara reached conservative political leaders and activist of the Islamic religion. When I saw 3 females amongst the 2000 odd males contesting for the title, I was appalled but somehow unsurprised---for it was a traditionally Islamic culture that pre-dominated the region.

What stuck the back of my mind was that there was not the slightest chance that a female would win the show. Period.

Post-film thoughts: I enjoyed the honesty portrayed in this film, in that it really pried open the truth from the contestants and people involved in the talent show. Including the fans and families of the contestants (at least they did try).

It was a controversial film that touched on many pertinent topics like religion, conservatism and politics in Afghanistan, which was particularly made more interesting with such a bold and head-strong director/host. He was a strong and creative talent that was prepared to speak his mind and did not conform to the oppressive rule of the Taliban.



What struck me in particular was the stark and somewhat uncomfortable lack of sponsors! Whereas American idol had several large Coke cups in front of every judges, and commercials plagued the broadcasting stations, banners and advertisements, Afghan Idol was completely stark naked, devoid of any form of sponsorship! This was exceptionally surprising for me, especially when I have so indoctrinated by commercials and its effects over the years. Could it be that no companies were brave enough to be seen overtly supporting such a daring and novel concept that deviated so strongly from Islamic culture and the conservative teachings of the religion?

Well, clearly we can see from Afghan Star, that passion exudes in many different form, regardless of culture, backgrounds and people. Take 9-months old Imron for example. He may be young, of a different culture and grew up in such a different environment from us, but like many, his passion for music can be felt by any other Idol-wannabes alike.